Need help - am working on TV show
Author |
Message |
Edward Justin Modestin #1 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Kate, dependent personality disorder fits into this definition. Ed Modestino M.Phil. candidate in psychobiology University of Pennsylvania Quote:
> Hi - > I'm working on the TV show JAG. I have a question. We're doing an episode in > which a witness (it's a show about Naval law, for those who haven't seen it) > has a psychiatric disorder which causes him to be so eager to please and so > fearful of disapproval that he will agree with anything anyone asks or tells > him. I know this sounds somewhat cartoonish, and I don't want to mock the > mentally ill. That's why I'm asking for your help - can anyone think of a > disorder which, in a very extreme form, could produce these symptoms? I'd > appreciate any and all theories, as long as they have a basis in psychiatric or > psychological theory. I work for the writers doing research, so if I can't > find an answer to this question, it's on my head and I want to keep my job!!! > Thanks in advance. If you want to respond to this email, please write directly > to me rather than posting on the newsgroup since I am not sure how often I'll > be able to get back and look at the newsgroup. > Kate Wharmby > JAG - Junior Writers' Assistant
|
Mon, 30 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Edward Justin Modestin #2 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
> Hi - > I'm working on the TV show JAG. I have a question. We're doing an episode in > which a witness (it's a show about Naval law, for those who haven't seen it) > has a psychiatric disorder which causes him to be so eager to please and so > fearful of disapproval that he will agree with anything anyone asks or tells > him. I know this sounds somewhat cartoonish, and I don't want to mock the > mentally ill. That's why I'm asking for your help - can anyone think of a > disorder which, in a very extreme form, could produce these symptoms? I'd > appreciate any and all theories, as long as they have a basis in psychiatric or > psychological theory. I work for the writers doing research, so if I can't > find an answer to this question, it's on my head and I want to keep my job!!! > Thanks in advance. If you want to respond to this email, please write directly > to me rather than posting on the newsgroup since I am not sure how often I'll > be able to get back and look at the newsgroup. > Kate Wharmby > JAG - Junior Writers' Assistant
|
Mon, 30 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Bureaucr #3 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Hi - I'm working on the TV show JAG. I have a question. We're doing an episode in which a witness (it's a show about Naval law, for those who haven't seen it) has a psychiatric disorder which causes him to be so eager to please and so fearful of disapproval that he will agree with anything anyone asks or tells him. I know this sounds somewhat cartoonish, and I don't want to mock the mentally ill. That's why I'm asking for your help - can anyone think of a disorder which, in a very extreme form, could produce these symptoms? I'd appreciate any and all theories, as long as they have a basis in psychiatric or psychological theory. I work for the writers doing research, so if I can't find an answer to this question, it's on my head and I want to keep my job!!! Thanks in advance. If you want to respond to this email, please write directly to me rather than posting on the newsgroup since I am not sure how often I'll be able to get back and look at the newsgroup. Kate Wharmby JAG - Junior Writers' Assistant
|
Tue, 31 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Emma Chase VanCot #4 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
: Hi - : I'm working on the TV show JAG. I have a question. We're doing an episode in : which a witness (it's a show about Naval law, for those who haven't seen it) : has a psychiatric disorder which causes him to be so eager to please and so : fearful of disapproval that he will agree with anything anyone asks or tells : him. I know this sounds somewhat cartoonish, and I don't want to mock the : mentally ill. That's why I'm asking for your help - can anyone think of a : disorder which, in a very extreme form, could produce these symptoms? I'd Why not pick up a copy of the DSM? -ECV
|
Tue, 31 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Larry Bras #5 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
> Kate, > dependent personality disorder fits into this definition.
> > Hi - > > I'm working on the TV show JAG. I have a question. We're doing an episode in > > which a witness (it's a show about Naval law, for those who haven't seen it) > > has a psychiatric disorder which causes him to be so eager to please and so > > fearful of disapproval that he will agree with anything anyone asks or tells > > him.
I'd agree that Dependent Personality Disorder (DSM-IV 301.6) is the only thing that would fit your description. Here is a little further information about this disorder. For a start, it is not a mental illness like schizophrenia or manic-depressive psychosis or even depression or anxiety. These are referred as Axis 1 disorders, while Personality disorders are designated as Axis 2. A personality disorder is defined in DSM -IV as: A. "An enduring pattern of inner experience and behaviour that deviates markedly from the expectations of the individual's culture. This pattern is manifested in two (or more) of the following areas: 1. cognition (ways of preceiving and interpreting self, other people or events). 2. affectivity (the range, intensity, lability and appropriateness of emotional response). 3. Interpersonal functioning 4. impulse control. B. The enduring pattern is inflexible and pervasive across arange of personal and social situations. C. The enduring pattern leads to clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning. Looking specifically at Dependent Personality Disorder, it is defined as: A pervasive and excessive need to be taken care of that leads to {*filter*} and clinging behaiour and fears of seperation, beginning by early {*filter*}hood and present in a variety of contexts and indicated by 5 (or more) of the following. 1. has difficulty making decisions without an excessive amount of advice and reassurance from others. 2. needs others to assume responsibility for most major areas of his or her life. 3. has difficulty expressing disagreements with others because of fear of loss of support or approval. (does not include realistic fears of retribution) 4. has difficulty initiating projects or doing things on his or her own (because of lack of self-confidence in judgement or abilities rather than lack of motivation or energy). 5. goes to excessive lengths to obtain nurturance and support from others. to the point of volunteering things that are unpleasant. [this is what you describe in your question] 6. feels uncomfortable or helpless when alone because of exaggerated fears of of being unable to care for oneself. 7. urgently seeks another relationship as a source of care and support when a close relationship ends. 8. is unrealistically preoccupied with fears of being left to take care of oneself. These features may help you to pad out the character a little more. --
|
Tue, 31 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Shape #6 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
>For a start, it is not a mental illness like schizophrenia or >manic-depressive psychosis or even depression or anxiety.
Larry, where do you draw the line? (Axis II = mental retardation and personality disorders, Axis I = everything else) -elizabeth
|
Tue, 31 Jul 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Larry Bras #7 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
> >For a start, it is not a mental illness like schizophrenia or > >manic-depressive psychosis or even depression or anxiety. > Larry, where do you draw the line?
A very blurred line at times when one tries to look at a person cross-sectionally. Personality disorder is a somewhat subjective and potentially judgemental description of someone's lifelong pattern of relating. It is therefore a longitudinal view of the person, but is so often wrongly used to describe someone's current behaviour (eg when in crisis or depressed) One should be wary of making this diagnosis in the presence of a Axis I diagnosis. The problem is that some subtle chronic depressive illnesses look like a personality disorder ("Borderline" being the classic example) until the depression responds to an SSRI and then the Axis II disappears. However, having said all that, I believe that personality disorders do exist, as there are many people who display remarkably maladaptive behaviours in the absence of any obvious Axis I disorder. I guess the diagnosis is a shorthand way of saying this person is likely to react in a particular way in a particular set of circumstances. Quote: > (Axis II = mental retardation and personality disorders, Axis I = everything > else)
--
Alt.anagrams FAQ Page. http://brash.net/anagrams/FAQ Anagrammy Awards. http://www.anagrammy.com/ National Geographic = Gaining a clear photo.
|
Fri, 03 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
rosaphi #8 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
personality disorders: narcissistic, histrionic, borderline. also: atypical disassociative disorder (cult-brainwashing type compliance due to mileu control, especially possible in a highly-structured military setting). also sociopathy. also schizoaffective disorder makes people very suggestible to magical thinking and suggestions perceived or real from others. and then there's always transference and countertransference when the role-model is just as pathological as the subject. are we having fun yet? +********** Snail me yer rosehips if you liked this post! ************ *Better Living Thru Better Living!* http://www.interport.net/~rugosa *
|
Sat, 11 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
<ricyo.. #9 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote: > > (Axis II = mental retardation and personality disorders, Axis I = everything > > else)
There are five axis (plural?) that psychiatrists are suppose to work with. Most dont bother Quote: > --
> Alt.anagrams FAQ Page. http://brash.net/anagrams/FAQ > Anagrammy Awards. http://www.anagrammy.com/ > National Geographic = Gaining a clear photo.
|
Sun, 12 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Shape #10 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
>A very blurred line at times when one tries to look at a person >cross-sectionally. Personality disorder is a somewhat subjective and >potentially judgemental description of someone's lifelong pattern of >relating. It is therefore a longitudinal view of the person, but is so >often wrongly used to describe someone's current behaviour (eg when in >crisis or depressed) >One should be wary of making this diagnosis in the presence of a Axis I >diagnosis. The problem is that some subtle chronic depressive illnesses >look like a personality disorder ("Borderline" being the classic >example) until the depression responds to an SSRI and then the Axis II >disappears. >However, having said all that, I believe that personality disorders do >exist, as there are many people who display remarkably maladaptive >behaviours in the absence of any obvious Axis I disorder. I guess the >diagnosis is a shorthand way of saying this person is likely to react in >a particular way in a particular set of circumstances.
Larry, I know this is old - I just wanted to say, very well thought out. Psychoanalysts I have talked to are reluctant to diagnose personality disorders (although they will diagnose clear-cut Axis I disorders like bipolar and panic disorder). They feel that it's better to look at a person's life problems on an individual basis, that's my understanding anyway. I sort of think that far too much effort has been put into classifying "personality disorders" and that we might do better to consider the utility of such a diagnosis - for example, I do think it's useful to note that self-mutilating behavior is an alarm bell for a history of childhood abuse. An interesting point about personality disorders being diagnosed on the basis of short-term behavior. A major depressive episode can go on for a long time, I think my longest one has been around 20 months. Other disorders can be chronic, like generalized anxiety or dysthymia. I wonder how many of these individuals get mislabelled as "personality disordered" only to make a quick and full recovery when properly treated with medication. Of course, it's also a popular myth that true personality disorders won't respond to medication, but generally both medication and talk therapy are required to obtain an improvement that is more than transient. -elizabeth
|
Mon, 13 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Shape #11 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
>There are five axis (plural?) that psychiatrists are suppose to work with. >Most dont bother
Axes. :-) Axis III is for general medical conditions that might be relevant - like diabetes mellitus, epilepsy, Alzheimer's disease, etc. Axis IV is psychosocial stressors, and Axis V is the global assessment of functioning score (number from 1-100, where 1 is the lowest level of overall functioning, 100 is the highest; 0 is "not enough information"). I had forgotten all about this thread. But did anyone see yesterday's episode of JAG? That was pretty entertaining. Good show. -elizabeth
|
Mon, 13 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
kdw #12 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
>I had forgotten all about this thread. But did anyone see yesterday's episode >of JAG? That was pretty entertaining. Good show.
If you're watching Jag, you need help, and a life.
|
Tue, 14 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Shape #13 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Quote:
>If you're watching Jag, you need help, and a life.
Hey, could be worse; I could be posting to Usenet! Oh, wait.... (To each his own...I think it's a pretty good show personally.) -elizabeth
|
Tue, 14 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
 |
Edward Justin Modestin #14 / 15
|
 Need help - am working on TV show
Long term intensive psychotherapy can help blunt maladaptive personality traits and ameliorate personality disorders. However, this takes years and the patient has to want to change. But, there is hope and it can work. Perhaps this reroutes different connections in the brain, creating new adaptive behaviors in response to events. This would be a sort of reconditioning of behaviors.
|
Wed, 15 Aug 2001 03:00:00 GMT |
|
|
1. Hot News About record shows. record tv shows,connecticut record shows,chicago record shows,record shows chicago,tivo record tv shows with tivo
2. record shows : Hot News. connecticut record shows,how to record tv shows,record tv shows for ipod,record shows chicago,record collectors shows
3. FOX TV 4/17/98 AM Show
4. Need info for Tv show on DMN
5. record shows : Actual News. connecticuyt record shows,connecticut record shows,record tv shows for ipod,record shows of america,chicago record shows
6. record shows : Recent News. connecticut record shows,record tv shows for ipod,record shows chicago,record television shows,how to record shows off dvr
7. Current News About record shows. vinyl record shows,connecticut record shows,record tv shows for ipod,used vinyl record shows seattle,record shows chicago
8. HELP: NEED MRI BUT AM CLA
9. HELP: Need MRI but am claustrophobic
10. HELP: Need MRI but am claustrophobic
11. I am losing the battle- Need help
|
|
|