
"Mass Gen Lands LD Expert"
Another Globe article- quotes Steere- and Steere was *wrong*- with long-term
antibiotic therapy Evan White is 100% today.
***********************************
************
HEADLINE: Lyme disease victim asks panel for help
SOURCE: The Boston Globe
DATE: August 6, 1993, Friday, City Edition
SECTION: NATIONAL/FOREIGN; Pg. 14
BYLINE: By Joel P. Engardio, Contributing Reporter
A frail, 14-year-old boy whose body has been ravaged by Lyme Disease held a
Senate panel in sympathetic awe yesterday as he pleaded for help in finding a
cure.
Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, the committee chairman, and many others in the hearing
room appeared moved by Evan White of New York, who Kennedy described as a
"brave, young man."
White, weighing only 80 pounds and bound to a wheelchair, usually does not have
the strength to speak, and communicates to his mother with barely audible words
and hand gestures.
But when his mother, Ruchana White, offered to translate for her son, he tried
to push her away to speak on his own. He managed to whisper into the
microphone. His mother repeated his words.
"We can't think. We can't sleep. We need you," he said of victims of the
disease. "We need everybody to work together to tell everybody how we feel."
Kennedy removed his glasses, wiped his eye, and after a pause, leaned forward
and spoke to the young witness.
"Of all the testimony today, those few words of yours will be the most
powerful," Kennedy said with a slight quaver in his voice. "You said it right.
I think the best way we can thank you is to make sure we do something about it
like you asked us."
Kennedy's Labor and Human Resources Committee was looking at the relatively new
and mysterious disease caused by bites from tiny deer ticks. First discovered
in Connecticut in 1976, Lyme Disease is highly concentrated in the Northeast,
although cases have been reported in 44 states. One of the "hot spots" of the
disease is Nantucket.
According to the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta, more than 9,600 Lyme
Disease cases were reported last year compared to about 500 in 1982. The
disease starts with flu-like symptoms and, if untreated, can progress to
conditions that affect the heart, nervous system and joints. Often, a slowly
expanding red rash will appear signaling a possible tick bite.
Some controversy has emerged over the treatment and diagnosis of Lyme Disease,
generating a few heated exchanges at the hearing. Many of the victims
complained they had trouble discovering the source of their strange illness,
and many doctors had dismissed their complaints as psychological while they
continued to suffer.
But Dr. Allen Steere, a professor at New England Medical Center in Boston, told
the panel Lyme Disease has become a "catch-all" diagnosis for difficult to
treat conditions. The chronic Lyme Disease many victims claim to have is rare,
Steere said, and the disease can be successfully treated early with 30 days of
{*filter*}medication.
"Confusing Lyme Disease with other illnesses runs the risk of taking Lyme
Disease research efforts down the wrong track and wasting scarce resources,"
Steere said.
Shouts of "He's wrong, he's wrong!" came from the audience in protest to
Steere's words. Many wore green ribbons on their chest to symbolize solidarity
in fighting the disease.
"If the doctor really looked around and saw all the children like Evan, he
would know they are chronically and critically ill," Mrs. White said. "He
cannot minimalize it because the people are here to testify it is happening and
it is everywhere."
Steere said he did not mean to say people like Evan do not have a problem, but
that Lyme Disease misdiagnosis is common. He said in 17 years of Lyme Disease
research he has not seen a case like Evan's.
When Sen. Howard M. Metzenbaum, an Ohio Democrat, pointed out that Steere's
testimony contradicted what others had been saying, the crowd erupted in
cheers.
"This testimony has been a clarion call. We ought to get off our butts and do
something about this," Metzenbaum told the audience, many of whom had the
disease or know someone who does. "We just owe it to you to try to find an
answer."