The Appeal of Anesthesiology 
Author Message
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology

        I was just curious if anyone out there had any personal antecdotes
about why they chose or did not choose anesthesiology as a profession.  It
seems like a really interesting area and I am interested in getting some of
the thoughts of what the medical profession feels about this speciality.

******************************************************************************



Sun, 09 Oct 1994 06:43:12 GMT
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology

Quote:

>    I was just curious if anyone out there had any personal antecdotes
>about why they chose or did not choose anesthesiology as a profession.  It
>seems like a really interesting area and I am interested in getting some of
>the thoughts of what the medical profession feels about this speciality.

Actually, I've had the same question about proctologists,
EXCEPT that I'm not considering it as a profession! :-) :-)

Jim Graham

        -> ->Disclaimer: I do not speak for my company. <- <-
                          Neither do they speak for me.
 ______________________________________________________________________


| BBS:      The PORTAL DOLMEN BBS/ParaNet ALPHA-GAMMA (sm) (9:1012/13) |
|            (812) 334-0418, 24hrs.                                    |
|______________________________________________________________________|



Sun, 09 Oct 1994 06:20:31 GMT
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology

Quote:

>        I was just curious if anyone out there had any personal antecdotes
>about why they chose or did not choose anesthesiology as a profession.  It
>seems like a really interesting area and I am interested in getting some of
>the thoughts of what the medical profession feels about this speciality.

  Well, in a nutshell...

Anesthesiology appeals to people who are action oriented but still
like to think about pharmacology and physiology.  The cognitive
profile of anesthesiology (at least in the OR -- it's different
for anesthesiologists who specialize in ICU or Pain Clinic work --
is one of dynamic decision making.  Many problems are observed,
recognized, and dealt with in cycles of seconds or minutes.  In
many other fields of medicine the cycles are minutes, hours, days,
or months.

There is not long term patient involvement in most parts of
anesthesiology which appeals to some people and does NOT appeal
to others.  One generally gets to care for one patient at a time
intensely, rather than jumping around (say on a medical ward) from
one patient to another all the time.  The intensity of the
patient-anesthesiologist relationship can for some people make up for
the lack of long-term involvement.  We do many cases under regional
anesthesia or local anesthesia and actually get to talk to them
for quite a while if they desire to be relatively awake.

Anesthesiologists get to see lots of different kinds of surgery.
Today I supervised residents doing anesthesia for neurosurgery,
opthalmology, urology, and podiatry (not all at the same time!).
I do anesthesia for heart surgery (including transplants),
thoracic, vascular, general surgery (abdominal), ENT, etc.  Lots
of interesting things in each of these areas both in the surgery
and in the anesthesia.

Our relative lack of constant patient-care responsibilities means
that we can have work schedules that are more humane than many
physicians must adopt.  When you work, you may work hard, but
when you go home you may get to relax (unless you are in academics,
or involved in medical economics, politics, etc.).

It is unusual to find someone who chooses anesthesiology and then
leaves for another medical field.  It does happen -- usually when
they have previous training in another field that they decide they
like better (or are better suited for).

There are negatives.  You will probably find (perhaps on the net!)
that many physicians don't really understand what anesthesiologists
do (just like we don't really know what dermatologists, psychiatrists,
etc. do).  There is a complex relationship between anesthesiologists
and surgeons -- this can be positive or negative depending on the
situation.  Anesthesiologists, like other physicians who have
traditionally done "procedures", have been earmarked to hav
our reimbur{*filter*}t reduced by the government, in order to redistribute
reimbur{*filter*}t to the "cognitive" specialties.  Economics aside,
I bristle at being labeled as "non-cognitive" since my research
work largely deals with the relatively unique (for medicine)
cognitive science of anesthesiology.

All in all, most who like a combination of science and practical
art with a very dynamic type of decision making and practice will
probably enjoy anesthesiology.  I do.

David Gaba, M.D.
Associate Professor of Anesthesiology
Stanford University School of Medicine



Mon, 10 Oct 1994 10:42:35 GMT
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology

Quote:
>situation.  Anesthesiologists, like other physicians who have
>traditionally done "procedures", have been earmarked to hav
>our reimbur{*filter*}t reduced by the government, in order to redistribute
>reimbur{*filter*}t to the "cognitive" specialties.  Economics aside,
>I bristle at being labeled as "non-cognitive" since my research
>work largely deals with the relatively unique (for medicine)
>cognitive science of anesthesiology.

David, I don't think there is an intent to label what you do as
"non-cognitive".  That would be absurd.  What is being said is
that "purely cognitive" work should be worth more than 10%
of cognitive plus doing procedures.  The amount I can bill for
spending an hour with my patient is probably about one tenth
of what you can, depending on what it is you are doing.   Maybe
even more if you have several rooms going with nurse-anesthetists
your a supervising.  I think radiology is the worst case of
abuse in this regard.  It badly distorts practice, and we find
neurologists with their own scanners deriving 90% of their
income from reading patient's scans rather than seeing their patients.
This is a real travesty.  Since you do take on risks that we
don't, some increment of compensation is justified, I think,
but nothing like what it is now.  Our anesthesiology department
is so wealthy, it is almost {*filter*}, while we have to bow and scrape
to the administration for everything we get, since we don't bring
in megabucks.  It also distorts anesthesiology, since you find
the some of the most materialistic medical students scrambling to
get into the field (along with ophthalmology, radiology, etc.) instead
of those who have a research interest, which is what I think
is such a good opportunity that anesthesiology provides.

--
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gordon Banks  N3JXP      | "I have given you an argument; I am not obliged

----------------------------------------------------------------------------



Tue, 11 Oct 1994 00:08:54 GMT
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology
There should be a personality questionnaire to give to medical students
to assist them in choosing a specialty, since (at least in my opinion),
matching personality to the style of the specialty makes people happier
and more effective.  The first question for budding anesthesiologists
should be:

1. Are you a morning person? (yes/no)  if no, pick another specialty!



Tue, 11 Oct 1994 05:10:48 GMT
 The Appeal of Anesthesiology

Quote:

> There should be a personality questionnaire to give to medical students
> to assist them in choosing a specialty, since (at least in my opinion),
> matching personality to the style of the specialty makes people happier
> and more effective.  The first question for budding anesthesiologists
> should be:

  There is, sort of.  I found it when determining the feasibility of getting
into medicine.  The title and author escapes me (I could dig it up for those
interested) but the Meyers-Briggs personality test was used to profile some
medical practicioners (e.g. neurologists _brainy introverts_ etc.).

Chris Magnuson
Software Development Engineer
Hewlett-Packard Company



Sat, 22 Oct 1994 07:40:20 GMT
 
 [ 6 post ] 

 Relevant Pages 

1. Residency program in Anesthesiology

2. Any conference in ANESTHESIOLOGY ?

3. anesthesiology?

4. general anesthesiology query

5. Anesthesiology information available via Gopher server

6. Anesthesiology

7. **** SCI.MED.ANESTHESIOLOGY ****

8. VR anesthesiology

9. Vr Anesthesiology

10. The study of anesthesiology.

11. Anesthesiology Newsgroups?


 
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software